If I were
to change the title of a short story I would change the title of Alice Sola Kim’s
“Mothers, Lock Up Your Daughters Because They Are Terrifying” to “Daughters
Lock Up Your Mothers Because They Are Terrifying”.
Kim’s
story revolves around the journey of three girls Mini, Caroline, and Ronnie and
how a supernatural being named Mom effected their lives. We learned the three
best friends were longing for individual attention, a support system, and a
relationship more than their friendship. When I first read this story, I never
understood the purpose of the title as it made the daughters seem like terrible
children. I deciphered the story as three girls who were struggling with family,
school, and simply managing stress. The girls weren’t terrifying rather they
were acting out because their parents weren’t fulfilling the position they
needed.
I switched
the title to “Daughters Lock Up Your Mothers Because They Are Terrifying”
because the supernatural being Mom was terrifying and should’ve remained locked
up. Mom impacted the girls negatively almost causing a car crash and pitting
the girls against one another. There life got “better” with Mom as it provided
them a sense of importance. They had someone who almost aggressively but openly
loved them. The girls enjoyed this until Mom made it a competition of who she
loved most. When Mom was locked up again the girls finally realized how
fortunate they were to have each other. Mom was the problem and the daughters
were her solution. Mom was locked up for a terrifying reason and Mini Caroline,
and Ronnie discovered that. She had the power of control and manipulation and
held it over the girl’s heads. Even Ronnie who didn’t fall into the trap was
forced to live with Mom in the end. The daughters should’ve never freed Mom and
Mom shouldn’t have locked them up.
I like your proposed alternative title! I don't think we got a chance to talk about the title in class, but I would've liked to. While titles usually feel like they're "outside" the story to some extent, in this case, the title seems to adopt a particular voice (maybe Mom's?). It's unusual for a title to take the form of a command. And you're absolutely right that the story shows that Mom is terrifying (while the daughters are vulnerable), so your title more accurately reflects the story's message. -Ms. O'Brien
ReplyDelete